Comparative strain typing of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae natural populations

372 natural isolates of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae, rescued from nodules of pea plants grown in an agricultural field in northern Italy, were analyzed by different methods. Three DNA-based fingerprinting techniques were lined up to compare their relative degree of resolution and possible advantages of each approach. The methods included (i) Eckhardt gel plasmid profiles, (ii) pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) of genomic large fragment digests, and (iii) random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) profiles, generated with arbitrary primers. The scheme also involved the isolation of a number of different isolates per nodule to estimate the level of intra-nodular variability. It was therefore possible to evaluate the frequency of double and multiple occupancies, and the proportion of the alternative profiles sharing the same nodule, generally resulting in a numerically dominant, main representative accompanied by a secondary one with a slightly different fingerprint. This finding revealed that the different profiles within a nodule are normally due to bacteria derived from the same single invader following genetic alterations possibly occurred during infection, e.g., by plasmid loss. The analysis of 31 nodules revealed 16 different patterns, representing the most frequently occurring nodulation-proficient isolates of the natural soil examined, five of which were found with frequencies around 15%. The sensitivity of the methods in differentiating isolates was compared. The relatedness of the different natural rhizobial isolates was investigated by densitometrical gel analysis of the fingerprints, allowing a comparison of the results. One of the most interesting conclusions was that the degree of information yielded by the plasmid gel profiling alone, carried out by simple visual inspection without software-aided analyses, was surprisingly high, as it enabled a placement of the isolates, whose accuracy, in terms of relatedness, was subsequently confirmed by each of the two genomic methods